Finflags

Transfers

IBAN discrimination

EU law bars employers, billers and public bodies from refusing a euro account over its IBAN country code. The ban has limits, and complaints go to a regulator.

·4 min read

A row of blank cards sheltering under a large umbrella in the rain, one card left outside it, beside a green flag
In this article
  1. What Article 9 forbids
  2. Refusals the rule covers and the ones it does not
  3. The Deutsche Bahn ruling
  4. How to report a refusal
  5. When a local IBAN is the quicker fix

IBAN discrimination is the refusal of a payment account because of the two letters at the start of its IBAN. An employer in Spain that pays salaries only into ES accounts practises it. So does an energy supplier in Germany whose direct debit form rejects an LT number the moment it is typed in.

The European Commission defines the practice as being unable to make or receive a SEPA credit transfer, or to pay by SEPA direct debit, from an account located in another member state. Spain’s central bank calls it a regular source of complaints.

Many complaints come from customers of app-based banks and payment institutions, whose IBAN carries the country of the provider’s licence or branch rather than the country where the customer lives. The Avici card comes with an Estonian IBAN issued by LHV Bank, and the euro account in Wirex One carries a Maltese one.

What Article 9 forbids

The ban sits in Article 9 of Regulation (EU) No 260/2012, the SEPA Regulation, under the heading “payment accessibility”. It binds both sides of a payment:

  • a payer sending a credit transfer may not specify the member state in which the payee’s account has to be located;
  • a payee who accepts credit transfers, or collects money by direct debit, may not specify the member state in which the payer’s account has to be located.

The only condition is reachability. Article 3 of the same regulation settles that point: a provider reachable for domestic euro transfers must also be reachable for transfers sent through a provider in any other member state. An account that receives SEPA payments at home therefore qualifies across the EU.

The protection extends to accounts at banks, payment institutions and electronic money institutions alike. An e-money account with its own IBAN stands on the same footing as an account at a high-street bank.

Refusals the rule covers and the ones it does not

Refusals the rule covers and the ones it does not
SituationStatus under Article 9
An employer pays salaries only into domestic IBANsBreach: the employer is a payer naming the member state
A utility, telecom company or insurer rejects a foreign IBAN on its direct debit mandateBreach: the company is a payee collecting by direct debit
A public body pays refunds only into domestic accountsBreach: public bodies are bound as payers and as payees
A payee in the EU refuses an account located in the UK or SwitzerlandOutside the rule, which protects accounts located in the Union
A payment runs in pounds, zloty or any currency other than the euroOutside the rule, which covers euro credit transfers and direct debits

One app can hold both kinds of account. Altery’s personal account pairs a Maltese IBAN for SEPA payments in euros with a GB IBAN for pounds, and of the two, Article 9 protects only the Maltese one.

The Deutsche Bahn ruling

The Court of Justice of the European Union tested Article 9 in case C-28/18. Austria’s consumer association, the Verein für Konsumenteninformation, challenged Deutsche Bahn over its online ticket sales, where customers could pay by SEPA direct debit only if they lived in Germany. The case reached Luxembourg on a reference from Austria’s Supreme Court.

On 5 September 2019 the court ruled that such a condition breaches Article 9(2). A residence requirement decides indirectly where the payer’s account must be held, which is exactly what the regulation forbids. The judgment also drew the outer limit of the rule. A payee remains free to offer direct debit or to leave it out entirely. What it may not do is offer direct debit to some EU accounts and refuse it to others.

How to report a refusal

A refusal often comes from a web form that validates only the domestic country code, and a written request to the company is the quickest first step. It should state that Article 9 of Regulation (EU) No 260/2012 requires the company to accept any reachable euro account in the EU, and it should include a screenshot of the error or the refusal. A formal complaint to the company follows if the answer repeats the refusal.

If the company holds its position, the case goes to the national competent authority in the country where the refusal happened. Article 10 obliges every member state to designate such an authority and names national central banks among the bodies that can take the role. Some countries split the work. In Spain the Banco de España handles cases against payment providers and disputes between businesses, while the consumer authorities of the autonomous communities handle refusals by a business to a consumer.

The European Commission publishes the full list of authorities on its page about IBAN discrimination. The same page asks people who meet the practice to fill in a two-minute feedback form, which the Commission uses to track how widespread the problem remains.

Member states also set the penalties for breaches. Article 11 requires them to be effective, proportionate and dissuasive, and the amounts are set in national law.

When a local IBAN is the quicker fix

A complaint can take weeks, and a salary or a rent payment cannot wait that long. App-based banks have started removing the problem at the source by issuing IBANs with the country code of the customer’s own market. The provider, the app and the card stay the same, and only the account number changes.

Revolut has moved customers in several EU countries onto local branches with national IBANs, including Belgium and Hungary. Bunq has extended local IBANs to seven countries, and Trade Republic issues them in seven as well. The new number then has to be passed to the employer and to each biller.

Before the new number goes out, the IBAN calculator confirms its length and check digits and shows whether the account sits in the EU, where Article 9 applies.

Written and checked by the Finflags editors. The date above is the date of the event. Fees, limits and terms change: tell us if something here is out of date.

Read next in Transfers